I know this seems like a funny title for a post, but stay with me…
Last week, after finding some very nice button-down shirts for my husband at a garage sale, he and I went through his existing shirt supply. We estimated how many shirts he needed for a typical work week, and then he tried on each one, including the ones we just purchased, and kept the ones he liked best. He kept some of the more worn shirts for shop/yard work, and the rest went into the donate/discard pile. While we were doing this, I joked that I should write a blog post called “The Life Cycle of a Shirt.” I was just kidding, but as we discussed it, we realized that our handling of his shirts illustrates an important frugal concept:
“Use it up, wear it out, make it do, or do without.”
This little saying is often touted by those who lived through the Great Depression, but in our current economy, we would all do well to remember it, and the way we buy clothing is a good example. We don’t often do without, but we also rarely run to a store to buy new clothes. We try our very best to make do with what we have until garage sale season comes around, because the vast majority of our clothing (with the exception of socks and undergarments), is purchased at garage sales. We typically pay 25 cents – $1 per item (more for coats and dresses – see my guidelines).
Some people have disdain for used clothing, but we certainly don’t. We find quality, name-brand clothing for a tiny fraction of the retail price, so to us, it just makes good sense. Everything is laundered and dried in a hot dryer before it’s worn – it’s really no different than store-bought clothing, which may be tried on by who knows how many people before you buy it and take it home.
When the clothing is worn out or outgrown, we do one of two things:
1) If it’s in good condition, we take it to a consignment store. If they accept it, we often earn back at least what we paid for it, and often more. If they don’t accept it (they’re quite picky), we try to find someone who can use it, because we’ve certainly benefited from hand-me-downs since having children, and it’s nice to pay it forward. If no one needs it, we donate it to Goodwill, Aid to Women, or another worthy charity, or save it for our next garage sale.
2) If it’s not in good condition, some of it becomes work clothing. My husband and I do most of our yard work, gardening, landscaping, home repairs, and remodeling ourselves, and he also does all of our auto repairs, so we always need clothes that can be ripped or stained without worry.
If we aren’t in need of work clothing, the clothes get delegated to the shop rag bin….but first we cut off and save the buttons for our button jar. These buttons are used to replace lost buttons on clothing, and also for crafts. I’ve also been known to save the back pockets of worn-out jeans – they make cute purses for little kids.
The shop rags are used for oil changes, paint drop cloths, grubby cleaning jobs, etc. You may have noticed in yesterday’s post that my husband was finishing trim on top of a piece of purple cloth – it was one of my old nursing gowns.
Many people (like my Grandma) keep scraps of old clothing to make quilts, but since I’m useless at sewing, I’m happy to delegate mine to the rag bin. We’re still getting every last bit of useful life from our clothing purchases, while saving money, and conserving resources too. I feel good about that.












{ 7 comments… read them below or add one }
Hi Heather – This is something you may want to add to your post. In the Chicago area, The Salvation Army takes bags of worn out clothing, etc. and sells it for rags (I don’t know who buys this from them). They make quite a bit of money off of this for their programs. So when I have too many items in the “rag” bin and I can’t use them all, I give them to the Salvation Army with a note on it to “please send to the warehouse for rag resale.” Maybe other charities do this as well?
Just FYI,
Kim
I love the frugal concept “use it up, wear it out, make it do or do without”. I think if everyone in this country would practice this, we would not be in the financial trouble we are in! It’s so refreshing to read such a sensible post! Thanks Heather…you keep us so grounded!
I have a favorite Goodwill store I haunt, er, frequent. I’ve had fabulous luck finding 2XLT shirts for the husband. I just tossed a “new” summer sleeveless Woolrich shirt in the laundry. I saw it on the shelf for $34, I paid $3. I happened upon a family friend there the other day. I don’t know if she was embarrassed to be seen there or startled to see ME there. Silly woman, does she seriously think I pay retail?!?
I was cleaning the husband’s dresser the other day and found alot of white t-shirts that had “shrunk”. I cut off the sleeves and collar band to make two very nice square rags. The sleeves went in my pile for some small cleaning tasks that I do.
Speaking of rehabbing clothes, husband wore out a collar on a dress shirt which otherwise was perfectly fine. He was ready to toss it. . . . and I took out my handy seam ripper, removed the collar, flipped it over and resewed it. Just like new!!
Yes, when buying new clothes, you never know how many people have tried them on, and, as my mother pointed out to me, you never know how many people have touched it while making and shipping it. That “new” garment was probably sitting on the floor of a ship or factory in China or Thailand, so it’s not as new and clean as one may think!
I love to sew and I am blessed with the skills to sew well. I like to take men’s cotton shirts and cut them apart. I press them and then use the roller cutter to cut the fabric into strips. Then when I can I sit at my machine and sew these strips together. They are all pre washed, won’t shrink, and together make a very pretty scrap quilt. I make several of these in a year and give them away as a Christmas gift. Little to almost no cost. I often use the lining from drapes (brought at the thrift store) for the backing of my quilts.
I don’t mind used clothes either, and I love getting a good deal! I have a friend that hates the thrift store. She says it smells and she feels like she has to take a shower when she comes out.
The idea of secondhand clothes freaks her out. But I reminded her that lots of people probably tried on the clothes she was wearing before the bought them, lol!
My husband delegates some of his jeans and tees as “work” clothes too, meaning he works on the car or works outside in them.
We have 5 children and often shop at cosignment shops, so thank you for sharing your clothes. Too many people just toss them out. We are also big into recycling things. There is enough waste in the world without our family contributing to more. We save a lot of money at these shops and our kids get much nicer clothes than we could get them if we just bought brand new clothes x 5 children. I love your tips! Great job!
Blessings,
Victoria
http://pinchincents.com